• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Wage Peace - Disrupt War

Strategic, bold, direct and discursive action to disrupt militarism in Australia and our region.

  • About Us
    • Making Change
    • Wage Peace Wins Global Peace Award 2023
    • Wage Peace, Disrupt War and Repair the Planet!
    • Smashing the Social License of an Industry Geared to Terrorise.
  • Campaigns
    • Disarm Australia
      • Demilitarise Education
        • BAE recruiting Year 6 kids
        • Demilitarise Education – Campaign Background Briefing
        • The military has invaded our classrooms.
        • Interrupting the Pipeline: Defence in STEM
        • Spotlight on UNSW
        • USyd Tied to Arms Industry
        • Demilitarise UQ: A Petition to UQ from an Autonomous Student Group
      • Stop Harms Dealers
        • ABC & Weapons Silence A Speech
        • Blockade Lockheed
        • Australia exports 155mm shell exports to Germany & the IDF.
        • No AUKUS: No Submarines!
        • Boeing is OUT OF CONTROL
          • Boeing, the Pentagon and Australian-based Propaganda Units
          • Boeing is a Weapons Corporation at UQ – Beware Boeing’s Wars
          • Trial of the Boeing Disrupters
        • Conversations with the Arms Dealers: Thales and the first of December
        • EOS – Just one more Merchant of Death
          • Is this justice? EOS arms deals to Saudi Arabia and UAE
        • Nioa Munitions: An excess of public money to fund police and the gun lobby
        • Nioa should rule out exporting weapons to Indonesia
        • Rheinmetall – making a killing
        • Stop Lockheed Martin
      • Legacy Campaigns
        • US out!
          • Fight to ditch the Aus-US Alliance
          • Close Pine Gap Website
          • Signing Up For War: The US Military Agreement With Australia You Probably Know Nothing About
        • Toxic SAS
          • SAS absorbed toxic US military culture
        • Whistleblowers
          • Support McBride – It’s About Exposing War Crimes
    • Frontier Wars
      • Frontier Wars
      • Frontier Wars Ceremonies
      • Boe Spearim’s Fabulous Frontier Wars Podcast – Must Listen!
      • Commemorating the Frontier Wars in Gimuy 2021
      • Frontier Wars – Lest We Forget 2021
      • Frontier Wars’ Desert Pea Wreath
      • Lest We Forget the Frontier Wars 2020 – online gathering
    • Peace In Papua
      • Peace In Papua
      • Peace In Papua – Thales, recall your bombs
      • War on West Papua
      • Make West Papua Safe, Australian Federal Police action
      • West Papua is Rising Up: Act now with Papuans to #MakeWestPapuaSafe
    • Disarm Police
      • Nine hours, no bullets!
      • NIOA – Arming the Intervention
  • Disrupt Land Forces
    • dlf 24
      • Report: Dangerous Policing DLF24
      • Journalist’s take on DLF 2024
      • Tactical Disruption Works
    • dlf 22
      • War Criminals need not apply; a summary of DLF22
      • Disrupt Land Forces 2022
      • Land Forces – A Killer of an Expo
      • Facilitating Exports: The Global Supply Chain and Landforces Brisbane
    • dlf 21
      • We massively disrupted the Land Forces weapons expo
      • Love against the machine – Land Forces 2021
      • Disrupt Land Forces – weapons company tour
  • Resources
    • Weapons Dealers in Australia: A Map
    • Peace Pod: an aural adventure in anti-militarist activism.
      • Get Your Armies Off Our Bodies: Trailer
      • Peace Pod launched!
      • Resources for Students
      • Resources for Teachers
      • Child’s Play? Militarism in the classroom
      • E5 Jangan Bunuh Kami Lagi / Stop Killing Us: West Papua Part 1
      • E6 Jangan Bunuh Kami Lagi / Stop Killing Us: West Papua Part 2
      • E8 We Need These Minds: MIlitarism in Universities
      • Revolving Doors, Corruption Gateways
      • War Stories
      • War Stories: BONUS – Afghan Peace Volunteers
    • References
    • Articles
      • The military industrial complex rides on the glamorous mythology of war
      • Doxxing and Security Culture
      • War = Peak Toxic Masculinity
      • War and Peace- articles by Andy Paine
  • Stop Arming Israel
    • Stop Arming Israel
    • Blockade Bisalloy: A Report from the ‘Gong
      • Bisalloy Makes Steel to Kill
    • F-35 Supply Chain
      • Taking Action Against Ferra and the F35
      • Nupress in the F35 Supply Chain – Newcastle
      • What’s Marand got to do with it?
      • Ferra Engineering, Boeing & the Queensland Government
    • Arms Embargo Now!
      • Nth Qld tungsten burns in Palestine
      • Harms Dealers: Thales in partnership with Israel Aerospace and Elbit.

Margie Pestorius

Submission to the #ADFInquiry

Graeme Dunstan

August 2017

To the Inspector General of the Australian Defence Force

Dear Sir,

As a deeply concerned Australian citizen, I want to contribute to the inquiry into rumours of possible breaches of the Laws of Armed Conflict by members of the Australian Defence Force (ADF) in Afghanistan, between 2005 and 2016.

Let me introduce myself.

I am a 75 year old Duntroon drop out who subsequently devoted his life to advocacy for peace and social justice, a nomad who travels around Australia in a van equipped with banner rigs and PA.

In many different public places and on many occasions i have been vocal in my opposition to the engagement of the ADF in US wars, first in Indo China and now the US wars without end in the Greater Middle East.

In particular I have been vocal about the corrupting influence on the Australian Special Air Service of extended service in Afghanistan (17 years!) under the command of US Joint Special Operations Command (SOCOM).

Service without accountability!

But while the Australian government has been successful in keeping the murderous business of the SAS secret from the Australian people and its media, enough information has come out from US and UK reporting to give us an understanding of what the Australian SAS have been doing.

In short this so called networked warfare has been murder and mayhem on a more or less daily basis for 17 years.

The best that can be said of the SOCOM strategy of systematic violence against Muslims and their indigenous communities in far away foreign lands is that it had some temporary success in reducing armed resistance to the US led invasion of their country. But it also produced ghastly blow-back, namely the rise of the Islamic State.

Then there is the human cost to consider. It is fantasy and delusion to believe that daily murder and mayhem comes without cost to the minds and spirits of those who perpetrate it.

In some these scars become overt as in PTSD, in others they may remain hidden in a persona of super efficient business as usual, either as commanders in the ADF or as corporate mercenaries and security personnel. Either way the benefit to civil society is negative.

In 2015 I was part of a peaceful protest against the SAS and it’s US war service at the gates of the SAS/ASIS base at Swan Island.

Eight of the protesters entered the base pre-dawn on Friday 10 October. Four were arrested by Victoria Police officers. Four others were apprehended by two ADF personnel in plain clothes (likely SAS) who hooded them, cable tied their wrists, cut off their clothes, assaulted and verbally abused them. See 7.30 Report here.

Raised at Senate Estimates the incident was later the subject of an inconsequential ADF internal inquiry. The assailants were not named. To the contrary they were deemed Protected Persons and as such declared immune from the processes of criminal law. A civil action against the ADF for damages is in train.

In the same way as a single litmus test shows a general acidity, I suggest that this abuse was not freak or abhorrent behaviour but rather an indicator of a general contempt – a SAS culture of contempt – for civilians and their civil law.

This is the war that the SAS has brought home from their long and irresponsible service to the failed US war in Afghanistan.

This violent form of policing has been referred to as “rendition”. It’s a CIA derived descriptor for what happened to Australian David Hicks when he was arrested, tortured and held without trial in Guantanama Bay 2001-07.

Worse I have reason to believe that at the time of the attack on the peace protesters, the Swan Island SAS was training State police counter terrorism units, plus counter terrorism police units from our Pacific neighbours, in just such policing techniques.

From a war of state terror in Afghanistan to training for state terror in Australia, it’s a pernicious consequence.

For this reason I want to address your inquiry.

The Swan Island assault is not a rumour. It actually happened though the perpetrators were protected. But isn’t that the way with the SAS and its cult of secrecy and why your inquiry is in progress?

At core what I want is to inquire of your inquiry what actions might be recommended to re-civilise the SAS into Australian civil society after its extended corruption under the command of US Special Operations Command.

Best we can.

For peace.

Swan Island Peace activists will have their day in court – in the news

You can support the Swan Island Peace activists in August…

Anti-war protesters sue the defence force. | Herald Sun

Swan Island intelligence accused of abusing protesters - Herald Sun article

Oct 2, 2017 – According to separate writs filed in the County Court the protectors intended to engage in a nonviolent protest and after hanging and taking photos of an anti-war banner on buildings separated into two pairs before being caught by plain clothes defence force personnel. Swan Island protester Greg Rolles … read more …

Swan Island protesters claim they were hooded and stripped at … – ABC

ABC News video: ASIS base protesters claim mistreatment in Guantanamo Bay style
Oct 9, 2014 – Swan Island, 90 minutes from Melbourne, is used for training by the Australian Secret Intelligence Agency (ASIS), the overseas arm of the country’s spy network. It is not open to the public without Defence or ASIS approval. Early last Thursday, eight protesters from the Swan Island Peace Convergence …

 

Defence Force Report into the Swan Island Trespass on 2 Oct 2014 (pdf)

Swan Island Peace Convergence

Website swanislandpeace.org
Facebook group Swan Island Peace Convergence

Peace Convergence

STOP THE EXERCISES | CLOSE THE BASES | END THE WARS

Wage Peace supports Peace Convergence – gatherings of peace activists from all around Australia who come together in a celebration of resistance to the biennial Talisman Saber US-Australian War Rehearsals.

Every two years, Australia hosts some of the world’s largest military operations, Exercise Talisman Saber, joint US-AUS combined force training which sees thousands of personnel engaging in land, sea and air manoeuvres: live firing, bombing practice, the use of sonar, on shore landings – and nuclear powered and nuclear-weapons-capable vessels. With support locations in cities around the country, the majority of the action takes place in Queensland, on and around the Great Barrier Reef, in the Northern Territory and in the Coral, Arafura and Timor Seas. Talisman Saber is expected to take place again in mid 2019.

Peace Convergence Website

Did Aussies really vote for these sociopaths?

JIM DOWLING. Feb 2017.

I walked into the kitchen the other day and our illustrious defence industries minister Chris Pyne was on the radio answering a question relating to the recent horrific suicide bombing in Kabul which left 100 dead and 250 wounded.

“No this was not a sophisticated military exercise”, he explained,  “But all Australians can see why we need to be there, still.”

Ah, usual dribble coming from a minister of war-making, I thought.  After all, last time I looked, most Australians were very dubious about our role in Afghanistan, including veterans of that war who are suiciding at terrible rates. Way back in 2003 polls showed 70% of Aussies did not support the pending invasion of Iraq. Pyne’s government took us there anyway, and Howard effectively doused most opposition with the line, “We may not all agree, but now we should all get behind our troops.”

As Pyne talked on, I discovered he was not talking about the problems of the Afghan people, but using their pain to help justify our Government’s latest noble goal of massively expanding our country’s international arms trading. He wants to loan nearly $4 Billion to any entrepreneurs with a similar goal. Pyne and Turnbull are hoping to make us one of the most successful merchants of death in the world. (Now we are a pathetic 20th in International arms sales. Shame!)

Now, I believe a sociopath is someone with no conscience, and certainly no interest in the truth; someone who will use even the most horrific acts to advance their own selfish goals. Yes, this seemed to be what I was hearing on the radio.

Now, I may not be thinking straight here, not being an expert in “defence” industries like Mr Pyne, but it struck me that the international arms industry may not the solution to the problem.  The strange thought even occurred to me that the arms merchants may even be the cause of some of this murder and mayhem engulfing Afghanistan.

Let’s have quick look at all those attempting to “defend” Afghanistan for the last 40 years and those supplying weapons for this important and difficult task. After the Russians invaded in 1979, the US and Saudi Arabia supplied most of the weapons used by the Afghan warlords and others to fight the Russians (who of course claimed they were the ones “defending” the Afghans.) Surely Pyne and Turnbull would have been happy to supply the Mujahedeen freedom fighters, if we only had a bigger “defence” industry at the time.  I am old enough to clearly remember Ronald Regan refer to the Mujahedeen as “freedom fighters” at the time. This is why he authorised the CIA to help fund the Pakistan maddrasses that established the Taliban and other terrorists (er, sorry, “freedom fighters”). One of those freedom fighters was Osama Bin Laden, of course.

When the dust settled and a million Afghans had died fighting the Russians, the warlords turned their weapons (er I mean defence exports from the US, Saudi Arabia, and Pakistan) on one another to see who would seize power. Kabul was decimated by a continuous new civil war. Enter the Taliban! They defeated all the warlords and “liberated” Kabul. Sadly the Taliban proved to be just as brutal as the warlords.

The Taliban gave refuge to Bin Laden in the hills of Afghanistan where he possibly organised the Sept11 attacks in New York. Osama never actually confessed to the attacks, but was later executed without trial by those great defenders of freedom we all know well. He did however admit he was at war with the US and gave 3 major reasons:

  1. US support for Israeli occupation and oppression in Palestine
  2. The blasphemy of infidel (ie US) troops being allowed to have bases in Saudi Arabia, the resting place of Mahomed, the revered founder of Islam . and,
  3. The devastation and death, especially of children, caused by 10 years of Iraq sanctions (The Australian Navy was in charge of the Naval blockade for a long time)

So 9/11 now meant the monster(s) we had created had gone feral and needed to be eliminated -“with extreme prejudice”. Unlike in Apocalypse Now, however, it was not just a matter of killing one man, but destroying two countries, Iraq and Afghanistan.  This Australia has helped do with great success.

Now back to the topic of real success, making money from the Arms Industry. (Time to really rub our hands together now, Malcolm and Chris!) Billions of dollars (probably more than a trillion) has been made by mostly US (British, French and others got some too, of course) weapons manufacturers in the so called “war on terror”. Just one little snippet about my favourite, the Raytheon corporation:  Within a week of 9/11 Raytheon shares rose a staggering 40%.  Of course, the average sociopath knew it was time to buy up big! You see Raytheon made the infamous Cruise missile at around $600,000 each (as well as smaller things like cluster bombs). Hundreds of Cruise missiles were dropped on Afghanistan and Iraq at the start of their respective wars, and hundreds more have been dropped since, as we continue to “defend” those poor people.

Seriously though, how 17 years of war proves we need to manufacture more weapons to make the world a better place I am not sure. Perhaps only a sociopath could work that one out.

The very day before I heard the above radio news item, I had finished reading the fascinating book, “Merchants of Menace” by Peter Butt. It is about the Nugan Hand Bank, a story which should be up there with Ned Kelly, but it is mostly unknown by present day Australians. It too has to do with arms dealers, (also drug dealers and money launderers).   In the 1970’s, Michael Hand, a much-decorated US Vietnam/CIA veteran teamed up with Aussie Frank Nugan to form the Nugan Hand Bank. They hoped to become as rich as possible, by any means necessary. The bank they started illegally laundered money for drug dealers, arms dealers, rogue states, and the CIA (though of course the CIA is above any law anywhere).

During the short life of the bank, before Frank Nugan shot himself (or was murdered), Hand went off to South Africa, Rhodesia, and elsewhere to sell arms himself, as well as helping the CIA supply them to rogue states. In 1980 after his partner, (and best friend for many years) Frank Nugan was found dead, Hand’s immediate comment to another business partner was, “Now the prick has left us to deal with this shit all by ourselves”. A sociopath, no doubt! Now , Mr Pyne thinks we can deal with the shit we helped create in Afghanistan by making more weapons, and no doubt selling them to the present “good guys” over there.

After much work, in 2015 Peter Butts finally tracked Michael Hand to a small town in the US where he had started a new life with a new name, despite numerous Australian appeals to the FBI to help  bring Hand to justice. Butts found Hand running a company to supply tactical weapons for US  Special Forces, Special Ops, and hunters.

Now I am sure Mr Pyne or Mr Turnbull could benefit from a visit to Mr Hand to find the secrets of his successful career.  After all Hand’s crimes of retail murder, drug dealing etc, are minor compared to the ones they will be complicit in when we become one of the world biggest arms dealers.  And, hey, maybe the ice trade could do with a few new faces as well………..

Oh yes, one more thing, if you think I am being too harsh on Turnbull and Pine, just watch Mr Turnbull, gleefully tell us the only thing the arms industry is about here: https://www.sbs.com.au/news/defence-exports-turnbull-unveils-3-8b-fund-to-boost-foreign-sales-of-australian-arms

_____________________

See also from this week more technical commentary from the Australian Business columnist Robin Bromby [read here temporarily pinned at WAGE PEACE facebook :)]

Or read at The Australian here

And from the Guardian:

“Australian government underwriting arms exports is ‘baffling’, expert says” 

Manufacturers have no trouble securing funding from private sources, Andrew Davies says

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 24
  • Page 25
  • Page 26

Footer

info@wagepeaceau.org

tel: 0403214422

SIGN UP DONATE
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • About Us
  • Campaigns
  • Disrupt Land Forces
  • Resources
  • Stop Arming Israel

Copyright © 2026 Wage Peace